VOLUME 3 (2001) - ISSUE 6 (WINTER)

Some Keys to compare French and German Traditional Concepts of Cultural Identity

by Hagen KORDES

SUMMARY

This chapter blends the traditional oppositions between Germany and France ; if French "assimilationism" is prima facie "inclusive", it is also "exclusive" (i.e. based on a form of a latent intolerance), as it does not admit anything else other than its own core identity and it represses all other languages and cultures. Conversely, German "marginalism" seems prima facie "exclusive", because it does not give citizenship to the migrants, but, at the same time, it is relatively tolerant, allowing them to differentiate themselves and to live according to their own standards.


KEYWORDS

Assimilation - Marginalism


AUTHOR'S PRESENTATION

Hagen KORDES is a sociologist and a professor at the University of Münster, Germany.


HOW TO CITE THIS SITE:

Author Name (Year), “Title”, in: The International Scope Review, Volume Number, Issue Number, TSCF Editions, Brussels.


ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

This book is the outcome of a collective reflection on immigration and interethnic relationships by a multidisciplinary academic team.

Translation in English by Patrick HUNOUT and Ellen MOORE-BOOHAR.

A part of this book has been realized thanks to the financial support of the Robert Bosch Foundation and the French-German Youth Office.


COPYRIGHT

All work published in The International Scope Review is subject to copyright and may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, in any manner or in any medium – unless written consent is given by The Social Capital Foundation represented by its President, unless the author’s name and the one of The International Scope Review as the first publication medium appear on the work or the excerpt, and unless no charge is made for the copy containing the work or excerpt.

Any demands for obtaining consent for reproduction should be sent to sg@socialcapital.is

Download

get_acrobat_reader.gif (712 bytes)

This is a PDF document.You may need  Acrobat Plugin to view it.